
The Carlyle
Best for cultural, classic New York: museum access, formal dining, and live cabaret.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Carlyle is a landmark Upper East Side five-star hotel known for Art Deco formality, classic dining, and a long-running cabaret—best for travelers who want old‑world New York and museum access. Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York is a glamorous Midtown five‑star with a high‑design crystal motif and modern luxury—read this if you want Midtown museum- and shopping‑centered stays with a designer look.
Updated · about 1.2 miles (≈1.9 km) apart

Best for cultural, classic New York: museum access, formal dining, and live cabaret.

Best for Midtown shopping-and-museum stays with a high-design, glamorous interior and a full spa and indoor pool.
When The Carlyle wins: choose The Carlyle if you value an historic, formal hotel with signature venues (Café Carlyle, Bemelmans Bar), easy access to Central Park and Museum Mile, and a quietly luxurious Upper East Side address.
When Baccarat wins: pick Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York if you want Midtown proximity to MoMA, 5th Avenue shopping, contemporary high-design interiors, and an on-site indoor pool and large spa program.
Bottom line: both are five-star New York hotels for luxury travelers; The Carlyle leans historic and cultural, Baccarat is more design-forward and Midtown‑centric. Your preference for neighborhood and hotel personality should decide it.
| Category | The Carlyle | Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Art Deco formality, discreet service, cabaret and classic bars | High-design, glamorous crystal-themed interiors and modern luxury |
| Location | Upper East Side, Madison Avenue; 1 block from Central Park and close to Museum Mile | Midtown Manhattan; steps from the Museum of Modern Art and near Rockefeller Center |
| Size (rooms) | 188 rooms and suites | 114 guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; not adults-only | |
| Pools | No guest swimming pool on site | Indoor pool (listed as 1 indoor pool) |
| Restaurants & bars | Dowling's (main dining), The Gallery (tea), Bemelmans Bar, Café Carlyle (cabaret), in-room dining | Grand Salon (French cuisine), bar/lounge, room service (limited hours) |
| Spa & wellness | Valmont Spa, signature 'Butterfly Motion' treatment, 24-hour fitness studio | Full-service spa on site, sauna, steam room and fitness facilities (listed) |
| Known for | Café Carlyle cabaret, Bemelmans Bar murals, classic New York service | Baccarat brand crystal aesthetic and proximity to MoMA and 5th Avenue |
| Accessibility / extras | Complimentary WiFi, valet parking (fee), concierge, family 'Rose Buds' amenities | Complimentary WiFi, valet parking (surcharge), concierge, babysitting (surcharge) |
| Typical guest | Culture-minded travelers, families and guests seeking classic formal service | Design-focused luxury travelers and Midtown shoppers/visitors to MoMA |
The Carlyle sits on Madison Avenue on the Upper East Side, one block from Central Park and close to Museum Mile.
Choose The Carlyle for a quieter, museum‑and‑park‑focused Upper East Side base.
Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York is in Midtown, steps from the Museum of Modern Art and near Rockefeller Center.
Pick Baccarat for immediate Midtown museum and shopping access.
The Carlyle offers 188 rooms and suites characterized by Art Deco detailing and traditional luxury service.
Rooms at The Carlyle emphasize classic finishes, larger historic suites, and family amenities.
Baccarat lists 114 guestrooms with Atelier, Classic and Grand Classic room types plus several suites.
Baccarat’s rooms lean contemporary and design-forward with signature crystal touches.
Dining at The Carlyle centers on long‑running New York institutions and a formal supper club.
The Carlyle is for travelers who want classic, theatrical dining and iconic bars.
Baccarat’s on-site dining highlights modern French cuisine with a glamorous dining room and a bar/lounge.
Baccarat suits guests seeking refined French dining in a modern, design-driven setting.
The Carlyle does not have a guest swimming pool; its signature amenities are cultural venues and an exclusive spa.
If a pool is essential, The Carlyle is not a match; its strengths are cultural programming and spa services.
Baccarat includes an indoor pool as part of its wellness and recreation offering alongside a full-service spa.
Baccarat is the better choice when an indoor pool and a strong spa program matter.
Wellness at The Carlyle centers on the Valmont Spa and a round‑the‑clock fitness studio; nightlife leans on in‑house cabaret and bars.
The Carlyle pairs an exclusive spa and in‑house nightlife rather than street-level clubbing.
Baccarat offers spa services, fitness facilities, and a Midtown location close to bars, restaurants and theaters.
Baccarat mixes in‑hotel wellness with easy access to Midtown nightlife and theaters.

The Carlyle — iconic Café Carlyle performances, Bemelmans Bar murals, and a traditional Upper East Side address.

Baccarat — steps from MoMA and 5th Avenue shopping with a design-forward hotel interior.

Baccarat — indoor pool plus a full-service spa and related facilities.

The Carlyle — family 'Rose Buds' program, complimentary infant cribs, and a quieter Upper East Side location near Museum Mile.
The Carlyle: it’s one block from Central Park. Baccarat is Midtown and farther from the park.
Baccarat lists an indoor pool. The Carlyle does not have a guest swimming pool.
Baccarat’s Midtown address puts you closer to MoMA, Rockefeller Center and 5th Avenue shopping; it’s the more convenient base for Midtown sightseeing.
Both welcome guests of all ages and are not adults-only; The Carlyle highlights family 'Rose Buds' amenities explicitly.
Explore how The Carlyle stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·