The Carlyle vs Nearby Hotels
Considering The Carlyle but want to compare other hotels nearby? These guides show how The Carlyle stacks up against popular alternatives.
Updated · 19 comparisons
All 19 The Carlyle Comparisons

The Carlyle vs The St. Regis New York
Compare The Carlyle (Upper East Side) vs The St. Regis New York (Fifth Avenue) — classic New York luxury, different neighborhood feels and service styles.
Compare →
The Carlyle vs Four Seasons Hotel New York
Classic Upper East Side glamour (The Carlyle) versus Midtown flag‑ship refinement (Four Seasons).
Compare →
The Carlyle vs Mandarin Oriental, New York
The Carlyle: classic Upper East Side luxury with cabaret and museum access. Mandarin Oriental: high‑rise modern luxury with spa and park/river views.
Compare →
The Carlyle vs The Ritz-Carlton New York, Central Park
Compare The Carlyle (Upper East Side) and The Ritz‑Carlton New York, Central Park for Park access, dining and evening entertainment.
Compare →The Carlyle vs Waldorf Astoria New York
Choose The Carlyle for Upper East Side culture and intimate cabaret; choose Waldorf Astoria New York for Midtown access and larger hotel scale.
Compare →
The Carlyle vs The Peninsula New York
Compare The Carlyle (Upper East Side) and The Peninsula New York (Fifth Avenue) for style, location, dining, spa, and pools.
Compare →
The Carlyle vs Park Hyatt New York
The Carlyle: classic Upper East Side landmark with cabaret; Park Hyatt New York: modern five‑star with pool and spa.
Compare →
The Carlyle vs The Mark
The Carlyle and The Mark are upscale Upper East Side rivals — pick heritage dining and cabaret at The Carlyle or a fashion‑forward stay at The Mark.
Compare →
The Carlyle vs The Pierre, A Taj Hotel, New York
Classic Upper East Side landmark (music & museums) vs Fifth Avenue park-front classic — two five-star New York icons.
Compare →
The Carlyle vs Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York
The Carlyle: Art Deco luxury and cabaret on the Upper East Side. Baccarat Hotel: Midtown glamour with a crystal aesthetic and an indoor pool.
Compare →
The Carlyle vs The Lowell
Compare The Carlyle and The Lowell for classic Uptown luxury versus discreet boutique refinement near Central Park.
Compare →
The Carlyle vs The Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad
Classic Upper East Side landmark with Café Carlyle and Valmont Spa vs contemporary Ritz‑Carlton NoMad with Zaytinya and club rooms.
Compare →
The Carlyle vs Trump International Hotel & Tower New York
Classic Upper East Side landmark with cabaret and Valmont Spa vs Columbus Circle tower with park-view suites and indoor pool.
Compare →
The Carlyle vs The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel
The Carlyle vs The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel — classic Madison Avenue landmark or recently relaunched Upper East Side luxury? Compare dining, spa and vibe.
Compare →
The Carlyle vs Lotte New York Palace
The Carlyle: Upper East Side five‑star with Café Carlyle, Bemelmans Bar and Valmont Spa; Lotte Palace: large Midtown landmark near Rockefeller Center.
Compare →
The Carlyle vs The Langham, New York, Fifth Avenue
Compare The Carlyle (Upper East Side) with The Langham (Fifth Avenue): classic NYC luxury and cabaret vs Midtown convenience and larger rooms.
Compare →
The Carlyle vs The Greenwich Hotel
The Carlyle: classic Upper East Side luxury with cabaret and museum access; The Greenwich Hotel: intimate Tribeca boutique with pools and design-focused rooms.
Compare →
The Carlyle vs The New York EDITION
Compare The Carlyle (Upper East Side) and The New York EDITION (Flatiron) — classic Art Deco luxury vs contemporary EDITION style.
Compare →
The Carlyle vs Casa Cipriani New York
Historic Upper East Side institution with cabaret and classic dining vs a small, clubby waterfront hotel near Battery Park.
Compare →
Reserve Afternoon Tea or Café Carlyle Seats
- Lowest rate guarantee
- Complimentary perks & upgrades
- 24/7 concierge