
The Carlyle
Best for refined, old‑world New York stays—museum walks, intimate bars and a legendary cabaret.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Carlyle is a refined, Art Deco five-star hotel on the Upper East Side, best for travelers after museum access, intimate dining and live cabaret. Lotte New York Palace is a large Midtown luxury landmark with cathedral and city-view rooms, aimed at guests who want a grand, central Midtown base near St. Patrick’s Cathedral and Rockefeller Center.
Updated · about 2.0 km apart

Best for refined, old‑world New York stays—museum walks, intimate bars and a legendary cabaret.

Best for a large Midtown presence with cathedral/skyline views, conference capacity and easy access to Rockefeller Center and Fifth Avenue.
When The Carlyle wins: choose The Carlyle if you want a quieter, more intimate luxury stay on the Upper East Side with signature venues (Bemelmans Bar, Café Carlyle), a boutique room count and an in‑house Valmont Spa.
When Lotte New York Palace wins: pick Lotte Palace if you want a big Midtown hotel with many rooms, cathedral or skyline views, stronger conference/event facilities and immediate access to Fifth Avenue and Rockefeller Center.
Bottom line: Both are luxury New York hotels but they serve different priorities—Carlyle for discrete, heritage-driven, small‑scale luxury; Lotte Palace for large-scale Midtown convenience and a more expansive hotel footprint.
| Category | The Carlyle | Lotte New York Palace |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Discreet, art‑deco, traditional luxury with live music and intimate public rooms | Large, landmark Midtown luxury with a palace-hotel scale and cathedral views |
| Location | Upper East Side; one block from Central Park and steps from Museum Mile | Midtown near St. Patrick's Cathedral, 5th Avenue and Rockefeller Center |
| Size (rooms) | 188 rooms and suites (hotel landmark scale, small‑hotel feel) | 909 guestrooms (large hotel) |
| Age / style | Art Deco landmark (opened 1930) with heritage interiors | Large-scale landmark hotel with a palace-hotel presence |
| Pool | No on‑site swimming pool | Wheelchair-accessible pool listed among amenities |
| Restaurants & bars | Dowling's, The Gallery (afternoon tea), Bemelmans Bar, Café Carlyle (cabaret) + in‑room dining | Gold Room, coffee shop/cafe, bar/lounge, room service (limited hours) |
| Spa & wellness | Valmont Spa (signature 'Butterfly Motion', Swiss Valmont products) and 24‑hour fitness studio | Full-service spa and a health club with steam room listed |
| Known for | Café Carlyle cabaret and Bemelmans Bar murals — evening entertainment and refined service | Midtown location and cathedral/skyline views close to Fifth Avenue and Rockefeller Center |
| Family / ages | Welcomes children of all ages; family amenities (Rose Buds program) | Family-friendly (not adults-only); family rooms and broad traveler recognition |
| Event & meeting space | Multiple named salons and ballrooms (Trianon, Versailles, Café Carlyle) for intimate to mid-size events | Extensive conference center and meeting rooms listed for larger events |
The Carlyle sits on Madison Avenue one block from Central Park and close to Museum Mile.
Choose The Carlyle if you want museum access, quieter Upper East Side streets and easy Central Park walks.
Lotte New York Palace places you in Midtown, steps from Fifth Avenue, Rockefeller Center and St. Patrick’s Cathedral.
Choose Lotte Palace for instant access to Midtown’s main sights and a central base for sightseeing or business.
The Carlyle has a compact inventory of rooms and suites with traditional, refined interiors.
The Carlyle suits travelers who prefer a smaller, service-driven luxury hotel with signature suites and heritage character.
Lotte New York Palace offers a large variety of room types including cathedral and skyline views and many suites.
Lotte Palace is better when you want choice of cathedral/skyline views or large suites for families or groups.
The Carlyle is known for classic dining and evening entertainment in intimate, storied venues.
Choose The Carlyle for evening entertainment, historic bars and formal dining in compact, atmospheric spaces.
Lotte Palace provides larger-scale dining outlets and a bar plus a coffee shop/cafe.
Lotte Palace works well for travelers who want straightforward, accessible dining in a larger hotel setting.
The Carlyle does not have a swimming pool; its distinguishing on‑site amenity is a full Valmont Spa and 24‑hour fitness studio.
If a hotel pool is essential, The Carlyle is not the right pick; its strengths are spa and fitness services.
Lotte Palace lists a wheelchair‑accessible pool plus a full‑service spa and health club.
Lotte Palace is the better choice when an on‑site pool plus mainstream spa/fitness facilities matter.
The Carlyle emphasizes a high-end spa program, evening cabaret and cocktail culture in compact, iconic rooms.
The Carlyle is ideal if you prioritize a signature spa and evenings with live piano or cabaret in close quarters.
Lotte Palace offers mainstream spa and fitness amenities and a more active Midtown scene outside the hotel.
Lotte Palace fits guests who want conventional on‑site wellness plus easy access to Midtown nightlife and theaters.

Café Carlyle and Bemelmans Bar give The Carlyle a unique evening-entertainment edge.

Lotte Palace puts you steps from Rockefeller Center, Fifth Avenue and St. Patrick’s Cathedral.

The Carlyle’s Valmont Spa is exclusive in New York for Valmont treatments and signature techniques.

Lotte Palace’s large room inventory and conference/meeting spaces suit big groups and events.
The Carlyle—located on Madison Avenue one block from Central Park and a short walk to the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Lotte New York Palace lists a wheelchair-accessible pool; The Carlyle does not have a swimming pool for guests.
Both hotels welcome guests of all ages and are not adults-only properties; The Carlyle also advertises family amenities via its 'Rose Buds' program.
The Carlyle is better for on‑site evening entertainment (Café Carlyle cabaret, Bemelmans Bar piano/jazz).
Explore how The Carlyle stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·