
The Carlyle
Best for classic, formal New York (museum visits, refined dining, cabaret nights).
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Carlyle is a five-star, Art Deco luxury hotel on Manhattan’s Upper East Side with formal dining, an acclaimed cabaret and a full-service Valmont Spa—best for travelers who want classic, museum-and-park-side Manhattan. The Greenwich Hotel is a five-star boutique in Tribeca favored by celebrities for its design-driven rooms, intimate service and downtown neighborhood vibe—best for those who want a private, design-forward stay in lower Manhattan.
Updated · about 7.3 km apart

Best for classic, formal New York (museum visits, refined dining, cabaret nights).

Best for a discreet, design-forward downtown stay with a neighborhood feel.
When The Carlyle wins: Choose The Carlyle if you want a formal, old‑world Manhattan experience near Central Park and Museum Mile, with legendary venues (Bemelmans Bar, Café Carlyle), ballroom event space and the Valmont Spa.
When The Greenwich Hotel wins: Choose The Greenwich Hotel if you prefer Tribeca’s low‑key luxury, individually styled rooms, an indoor/outdoor pool option and a property that reads more like a private downtown house than a grand hotel.
Bottom line: Both are five‑star New York hotels that deliver high service and on-site spas; pick The Carlyle for classic Upper East Side formality, museums and cabaret, or The Greenwich for downtown design character and a more intimate, celebrity‑leaning vibe.
| Category | The Carlyle | The Greenwich Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Art Deco, formal, classic New York luxury | Boutique, design-driven, intimate |
| Location | Upper East Side — one block from Central Park and close to Museum Mile | Tribeca — downtown, quiet residential and cast‑iron streets with restaurants and galleries |
| Size | 188 rooms and suites | Not published |
| Rooms — typical names | Multiple suites and room categories (e.g., Suite (Carlyle), Premier Suite, Superior Room) | Superior King Room; Deluxe King Room; Studio Suite; Fireplace Corner Suite; SUITE Corner Suite; more |
| Pools | No guest swimming pool (fitness center and spa only) | Indoor and outdoor swimming pool options listed |
| Restaurants & bars | Dowling's (main restaurant), The Gallery (tea/all‑day), Bemelmans Bar (iconic piano/jazz), Café Carlyle (cabaret) | On-site restaurants, poolside bar, coffee shop and restaurant options listed |
| Spa & wellness | Valmont Spa with signature 'Butterfly Motion' treatment; 24-hour fitness studio | Full spa and massage services plus yoga room and fitness options listed |
| Known for | Historic glamour, live cabaret at Café Carlyle and Bemelmans Bar murals | Downtown exclusivity, design character and celebrity clientele |
| Family / age policy | All ages welcome; not adults-only | |
| Accessibility & services | Complimentary Wi‑Fi, valet parking, concierge, ADA rooms on request | Free Wi‑Fi, concierge, valet/nearby parking, wheelchair accessible |
The Carlyle sits on Madison Avenue a block from Central Park and close to Museum Mile.
Choose The Carlyle if proximity to Central Park and Museum Mile matters most.
The Greenwich Hotel is on Greenwich Street in Tribeca, a quieter, lower Manhattan neighborhood.
Choose The Greenwich Hotel for a downtown, low‑profile neighborhood stay.
The Carlyle offers a broad range of formally styled rooms and named suites reflecting its Art Deco heritage.
The Carlyle suits travelers who want traditional, formal suite options and a variety of room categories.
The Greenwich Hotel lists a selection of design-forward room types and several suite options.
The Greenwich Hotel suits travelers looking for distinctive, design-led rooms in Tribeca.
The Carlyle centers its food and beverage around classic, formal venues and live entertainment.
Pick The Carlyle if classic, formal dining and live cabaret are priorities.
The Greenwich Hotel provides on-site restaurant options and casual bars aligned with its boutique character.
Choose The Greenwich Hotel for a more casual, neighborhood dining experience with on-site options.
The Carlyle does not offer a guest swimming pool; its signature amenities are dining, cabaret and the Valmont Spa.
If an on‑site pool is essential, The Carlyle is not the right pick.
The Greenwich Hotel lists both indoor and outdoor swimming pool options as part of its amenities.
Choose The Greenwich Hotel if an on‑site pool is important to your stay.
The Carlyle mixes a full-service Valmont Spa and a 24‑hour fitness studio with iconic evening venues.
The Carlyle pairs serious spa and fitness facilities with established live-music nightlife.
The Greenwich Hotel offers spa and massage services plus neighborhood nightlife in Tribeca.
The Greenwich Hotel is better for quieter, design-led wellness and easy access to Tribeca nightlife.

The Carlyle — one block from Central Park and a short walk to the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

The Greenwich Hotel — Tribeca location, individually styled rooms and a low-key, celebrity-favored atmosphere.

The Carlyle — Café Carlyle and Bemelmans Bar provide regular live performances and a classic New York nightlife setting.

The Greenwich Hotel — supplier listing includes indoor and outdoor swimming pool options.
The Carlyle is closer — it sits one block from Central Park and is a short walk to the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
No — The Carlyle does not have a guest swimming pool; The Greenwich Hotel lists indoor and outdoor pools.
No — both properties welcome guests of all ages and are not adults-only.
The Greenwich Hotel is widely described as a celebrity-favored, low-profile Tribeca boutique; The Carlyle is more public and formal.
Explore how The Carlyle stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·