
The Carlyle
Best for travelers who want a traditional, service-forward luxury stay with signature dining, live cabaret and a dedicated spa.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Carlyle is a landmark, Art Deco five-star hotel on the Upper East Side known for refined service, a Valmont spa, Café Carlyle cabaret and classic bars — for travelers who want old‑world Manhattan and museum access. The New York EDITION is a design-led, five-star EDITION property near Madison Square Park and the Flatiron Building — for travelers looking for contemporary style and a central downtown location.
Updated · about 4.3 km apart

Best for travelers who want a traditional, service-forward luxury stay with signature dining, live cabaret and a dedicated spa.

Best for travelers who prefer a contemporary, design-focused luxury hotel in the Flatiron/Madison Square area with strong brand recognition.
When The Carlyle wins: choose The Carlyle if you value a historic, formal Manhattan experience, easy walking access to Central Park and Museum Mile, late-night piano/jazz at Bemelmans Bar or the Café Carlyle cabaret.
When The New York EDITION wins: pick The New York EDITION if you want a more contemporary, design-led property close to Madison Square Park, the Flatiron Building and downtown attractions, and you prefer the EDITION brand vibe.
Bottom line: both are five-star Manhattan hotels offering high service standards; choose based on neighborhood and style — The Carlyle for classic Upper East Side refinement and arts-focused programming, The New York EDITION for modern design and a Flatiron/Madison Square Park location.
| Category | The Carlyle | The New York EDITION |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, Art Deco, formal luxury with cabaret and classic bars | Contemporary, design-led EDITION lifestyle hotel |
| Location | Upper East Side, one block from Central Park and close to Museum Mile | Madison Square Park / Flatiron area, steps from Madison Square Park |
| Size (rooms) | 188 rooms and suites | 271 air-conditioned rooms |
| Age / building style | Art Deco landmark building (opened 1930) | Modern conversion/designed property (contemporary EDITION look) |
| Pools | No pool (The Carlyle does not have a swimming pool for guests) | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Dowling's, The Gallery (afternoon tea), Bemelmans Bar, Café Carlyle, in-room dining | The Clocktower restaurant, 2 bars/lounges, 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | Valmont Spa (signature 'Butterfly Motion'), 24-hour fitness studio | Onsite massages and facials; fitness facilities listed |
| Meeting & event space | Multiple historic event rooms (Trianon, Versailles, Café Carlyle) and over 2,300 sq ft of event space | 2100 sq ft conference space and 5 meeting rooms |
| Nearby highlights | Central Park, Metropolitan Museum of Art, Museum Mile, Madison Avenue shopping | Madison Square Park, Flatiron Building, Empire State Building within ~1 km |
| Family / age policy | All ages welcome; family amenities (Rose Buds) and childcare options | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
| Wi‑Fi & essential services | Complimentary WiFi, 24-hour front desk, concierge, in-room dining | |
The Carlyle sits on Madison Avenue one block from Central Park and close to Museum Mile.
Choose The Carlyle for proximity to Central Park, museum visits and a quieter, uptown neighborhood.
The New York EDITION is steps from Madison Square Park and the Flatiron Building in lower Midtown/Flatiron.
Choose The New York EDITION for a central Flatiron location within easy reach of downtown Midtown attractions.
The Carlyle offers a relatively small inventory of traditionally styled rooms and many named suites.
The Carlyle suits travelers who want classic, individually appointed rooms and notable suites tied to the hotel's history.
The New York EDITION lists 271 air-conditioned rooms with contemporary styling and Smart TVs.
The New York EDITION suits travelers who prefer contemporary room design and a larger selection of modern room types.
The Carlyle is known for multiple classic venues — a main restaurant, afternoon tea, a legendary bar and a cabaret.
Pick The Carlyle for varied, historic dining options and live entertainment in-house.
The New York EDITION features The Clocktower restaurant, two bars/lounges and 24-hour room service.
The New York EDITION fits travelers seeking contemporary restaurant and bar options in a design-focused setting.
The Carlyle does not have a guest swimming pool; its notable amenities are spa and cabaret venues.
If an on-site pool is important, the Carlyle is not the right choice; prioritize its spa and fitness offerings instead.
The New York EDITION lists spa treatments and fitness facilities but supplier materials do not publish a pool.
The New York EDITION focuses on design, dining and fitness/spa services; a pool is not published in supplier materials.
The Carlyle blends an exclusive spa program with late-night live music and cabaret.
The Carlyle is a good match for travelers who want in-house spa services plus evening live music and cabaret.
The New York EDITION emphasizes contemporary bars/lounges and nearby downtown nightlife.
The New York EDITION suits travelers who want modern bar lounges and easy access to the Flatiron/Union Square nightlife.

The Carlyle — historic Art Deco rooms, Café Carlyle cabaret and Bemelmans Bar create a traditional Manhattan luxury experience.

The New York EDITION — modern EDITION design, central Flatiron/Madison Square Park location and larger room inventory.

The Carlyle — one block from Central Park and within easy walking distance of the Met and Museum Mile.

The New York EDITION — steps from Madison Square Park and Flatiron Building, convenient for Midtown/downtown attractions.
The Carlyle is much closer — it's one block from Central Park and about a 7-minute walk to the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
The Carlyle does not have a guest pool. The New York EDITION's supplier listing does not publish a pool either.
The Carlyle offers in-house dining and live cabaret; The New York EDITION places you in the Flatiron/Union Square dining and bar scene. Choose based on whether you prefer in‑hotel entertainment (Carlyle) or walking to downtown restaurants (EDITION).
No — both hotels welcome guests of all ages and are not marketed as adults-only properties.
Explore how The Carlyle stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·