
The Carlyle
Best for museum‑mile stays, quiet elegance, and evening cabaret at Café Carlyle.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Carlyle is an Upper East Side, Art Deco five-star hotel known for quiet refinement, classic dining venues, and an intimate cabaret scene — read this if you want old‑world service, museum‑mile access, or a quieter Manhattan base. The St. Regis New York is a grand Fifth Avenue five‑star with Butler service and Midtown convenience — read this if you prefer a landmark Fifth Avenue address, formal service, and easy access to Rockefeller Center and Midtown theaters.
Updated · about 1.7 km apart

Best for museum‑mile stays, quiet elegance, and evening cabaret at Café Carlyle.

Best for a central Midtown location, formal butler service, and Fifth Avenue shopping steps away.
When The Carlyle wins: Choose The Carlyle if you value an Upper East Side address by Central Park and the Met, evening piano and cabaret at Bemelmans Bar and Café Carlyle, and a smaller, discreet hotel with strong spa and salon services.
When The St. Regis New York wins: Choose The St. Regis if you want a classic Fifth Avenue luxury landmark close to Rockefeller Center, formal in‑room butler service across many room categories, and more on‑site meeting/banquet capacity in Midtown.
Bottom line: Both are five‑star New York institutions offering classic luxury; pick The Carlyle for a quieter, museum‑focused Upper East Side experience with famed live entertainment, and pick The St. Regis New York for a Fifth Avenue Midtown base with butler service and easy access to Rockefeller Center and Broadway.
| Category | The Carlyle | The St. Regis New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Quiet, Art Deco refinement with a focus on discreet service and evening cabaret. | Grand, Fifth Avenue luxury with formal service and a classic hotel presence. |
| Location | Upper East Side (35 E 76th St), one block from Central Park and close to Museum Mile. | Midtown/Fifth Avenue (Two East 55th St), steps from 5th Avenue and near Rockefeller Center. |
| Size (rooms) | 188 rooms and suites. | 238 air‑conditioned guestrooms. |
| Age / heritage | Art Deco landmark (opened 1930). | Iconic grand‑luxury Fifth Avenue hotel (longstanding New York name). |
| Pools | No swimming pool for guests. | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Dowling's, The Gallery (afternoon tea), Café Carlyle (cabaret), Bemelmans Bar, plus in‑room dining. | Two restaurants and one bar/lounge; room service (limited hours); breakfast available for a surcharge. |
| Spa & fitness | Valmont Spa (signature 'Butterfly Motion'), Yves Durif Salon, 24‑hour fitness studio. | 24‑hour fitness facilities; spa details not published in supplier listing. |
| Known for | Café Carlyle cabaret and Bemelmans Bar murals and piano music. | Butler service and Fifth Avenue address near top Midtown attractions. |
| Meetings & events | Several distinctive event rooms including Trianon and Versailles Suites; multiple private event capacities. | 13 meeting rooms and ~3,944 sq ft of conference space; ballroom and banquet facilities. |
| Accessibility & family policy | Welcomes children of all ages; main guest must be 18 to check in; family 'Rose Buds' program. | Welcomes guests of all orientations and ages; minimum check‑in age 21 per supplier policy. |
The Carlyle sits on Madison Avenue, one block from Central Park and near Museum Mile.
Choose The Carlyle for museum access, quiet streets, and an Upper East Side neighborhood feel.
The St. Regis New York sits on Two East 55th St, immediately adjacent to Fifth Avenue retail and Midtown sights.
Choose The St. Regis New York for a classic Fifth Avenue address and immediate Midtown access.
The Carlyle offers 188 rooms and suites with an emphasis on refined decor and discrete service.
Rooms suit travelers who prioritize classic New York luxury and access to the hotel's intimate amenities.
The St. Regis New York lists many room types (including Butler Service options) across 238 guestrooms.
Rooms suit travelers who want formal butler service and a traditional Fifth Avenue hotel experience.
Dining at The Carlyle is a major draw: Dowling's, The Gallery, Bemelmans Bar and Café Carlyle provide variety and evenings with live music.
Pick The Carlyle for iconic bars, live music, and late‑evening cabaret.
The St. Regis New York offers two restaurants and a bar/lounge, with room service available during limited hours.
Pick The St. Regis New York if you want formal in‑hotel service and a central spot for Midtown dining and shopping.
The Carlyle does not have a swimming pool; signature amenities center on spa, salon and live entertainment.
Expect spa and fitness rather than a pool when staying at The Carlyle.
The St. Regis New York lists a 24‑hour fitness facility and many guest services; on‑site pool information is not published in the supplier listing.
St. Regis emphasizes formal service and fitness; pool availability is not published and should be confirmed directly.
The Carlyle combines a full‑service Valmont Spa, 24‑hour fitness studio, and a famed nightlife program focused on piano and cabaret.
Wellness plus nightly live entertainment is core to The Carlyle's appeal.
The St. Regis New York provides a 24‑hour fitness facility and a single bar/lounge; nightlife and spa programming are less emphasized in the supplier listing.
St. Regis offers steady hotel nightlife and fitness; check current listings for live‑music or spa programming.

The Carlyle — one block from Central Park and walking distance to the Met and Museum Mile.

The St. Regis New York — located on East 55th Street steps from 5th Avenue shopping and Rockefeller Center.

The Carlyle — Café Carlyle and Bemelmans Bar offer scheduled performances and nightly piano music.

The St. Regis New York — many room types explicitly include Butler Service.
The Carlyle — it sits one block from Central Park; The St. Regis New York is several blocks south of the park.
The Carlyle does not have a swimming pool. The St. Regis New York's supplier listing does not publish pool details; confirm directly with the hotel.
The Carlyle is better known for evening entertainment (Café Carlyle cabaret, Bemelmans Bar piano and jazz).
Breakfast is available at both properties but is typically offered for an additional fee rather than included automatically in standard room rates.
Explore how The Carlyle stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·